Although an agreement was reached to advance government bills through their concluding stages before the House of Commons adjourned last Thursday, two key pieces of budget and border legislation, C-4 and C-12, will not become law until at least February.
This year, the Senate did not meet an additional week beyond the House of Commons, meaning that late legislation is unable to pass through the upper chamber and receive royal assent until Parliament reconvenes after its two-month break.
Chloé Fedio, the communications director for Pierre Moreau, the government’s representative in the Senate, stated in an email to CBC News that the upper chamber preferred to avoid rushing the process.
“Bill C-4 and Bill C-12 are intricate pieces of legislation that the Senate plans to examine in the new year,” Fedio mentioned. “There was no agreement to hurry these two bills through the Senate within a week.”
“Senate leadership will formulate a strategy to guarantee that these legislative items are thoroughly reviewed when the Senate reconvenes on February 3.”
Fedio also highlighted that on November 26, the Senate decided to commence its examination of the government’s fall budget implementation bill, C-15, across 11 different committees. She indicated that this collaboration with the Carney government’s latest priorities limited senators’ capacity to pre-study other bills such as C-4 and C-12 prior to the winter recess.
The office of Government House leader Steven MacKinnon informed CBC News that while it respects the Senate’s decisions, it is pleased to witness both bills progress to the stage of having cleared the House.
House accelerates activity
Following months of delayed legislation in the 44th Parliament, senators expressed frustration last June when Prime Minister Mark Carney’s recently elected government pressured the Senate to hasten the Liberals’ new agenda in the 45th.
“Government officials will understandably always strive to advance their agenda through Parliament as swiftly as possible, yet expediency should not sacrifice our standard legislative procedures,” Alberta Sen. Scott Tannas wrote earlier this fall.
Tannas shared concerns echoed by many of his peers regarding the growing tendency to utilize large omnibus bills, which are difficult for senators to review in detail within a short timeframe.
“Our bicameral system was intentionally designed to ensure that regional representation and minority interests are central to the lawmaking process,” Tannas remarked.
“Frequently, in the rush to pass legislation before adjournment periods, senators encounter pressure to avoid amendments because MPs have departed Ottawa.”
According to the Senate’s published sitting calendar, December 11 was set as its last sitting day for 2025. The House of Commons was scheduled to adjourn on December 12.
However, in some years, the Senate remains in session longer than the Commons before taking its extended winter and summer breaks.
It is not unusual for legislation to conclude final stages in the House at the last moment as legislative matters are resolved before recess. When appointed senators continue working a bit longer than elected MPs, there is a chance to swiftly ensure that priority bills become law, especially if the measures are time-sensitive and their eventual approval is assured.
Last-minute agreement in Commons
Last Thursday, following the concluding question period in the Commons for 2025, MacKinnon sought and obtained unanimous support from MPs to advance both Bill C-4 and C-12 at third reading without a standing vote, sending both bills to the Senate.
C-4 had undergone extensive debate since its introduction in June. It formally endorses the personal income tax reduction, alterations to the consumer carbon tax, and the GST rebate for new homebuyers that the Liberals had already implemented last summer. Additionally, it modifies the requirements for how political parties safeguard personal information under the Canada Elections Act.
-
Analysis
Are there ‘snooping provisions’ in Carney’s massive border bill?
-
With Bill C-2’s fate uncertain, spy agency argues its ability to do its job ‘eroding’
The Senate took initiatives to expedite C-4 last June, including inviting Finance Minister François-Philippe Champagne for special committee testimony on June 17. However, that urgency to pre-study its provisions became somewhat irrelevant when C-4 did not clear the Commons before the summer recess.
Provisions in C-12 were initially introduced in late May as components of C-2, the Carney government’s first attempt at omnibus border security legislation. When certain aspects of C-2 sparked controversy during heated discussions over its “snooping” provisions, among others, the government removed sections it believed could garner enough opposition support for a swift passage and reintroduced only those provisions as C-12 in October.
Amendments to C-12 were voted on at the report stage following the question period on Thursday afternoon. Shortly after, the House agreed to skip any further debate and allow C-12 to clear the Commons as well, as part of MacKinnon’s all-party agreement.
This same agreement also enabled C-13, the legislation to facilitate the United Kingdom’s accession to the Comprehensive and Progressive Trans-Pacific Partnership trade agreement, to pass second reading without a standing vote and proceed to a House committee for additional examination.
The House of Commons adjourned at 4:18 p.m., with the Senate following suit just five minutes later at 4:23 p.m. All parliamentarians are now on their holiday break for two months.
The House is set to reconvene on January 26, while the Senate will resume its sessions the following week on February 3.
